Actions

Work Header

Welcome to Pettyville

Summary:

When Lily Evans accidentally sends a text to the wrong number, she isn’t expecting to find the right person behind it. She can’t stop talking to Prongs. The only thing is, Prongs can’t stop talking about the girl in his class. What could go wrong, other than the number?

Notes:

The newest production from Ginger in the Sequel!

Updates every Friday!

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Chapter 1: Hey, I Just Met You

Chapter Text

Missed call from New Number

Missed call from New Number

Missed call from New Number

New Number: guess I have to do this here since you apparently aren’t answering your phone

New Number: WTF was that????

New Number: I already know that you’re going to say I’m overreacting

New Number: but I don’t even care rn

New Number: you do this and then ignore me?

New Number: I can’t believe this

New Number: actually I can

New Number: you didn’t bother sticking around but jsyk EVERYTHING is gone

New Number: I don’t know what you’re telling yourself I did to deserve this but

New Number: whatever

New Number: at first I wanted you to say sorry but I don’t even know if I care anymore

Me: Ummm…

Me: I’m really sorry about whoever wronged you at such an ungodly hour when they should be sleeping

Me: But I’m pretty sure you have the wrong number

New Number: ???

Me: At least I’m assuming so

Me: I don’t recall any acts of wrongdoing on my part in the past 24 hours

New Number: is this some kind of prank?

New Number: you've had the same number since you were 15

Me: 14 actually

Me: But that is beside the point

Me: I solemnly swear to you, wrong number, that this is not a prank of mine

Me: You have honestly texted the wrong number and not whoever you’re looking for

New Number: OH MY GOD

New Number: just checked the number

New Number: I am so sorry

New Number: I was angry (obviously) and must have typed it wrong

New Number: I'm so sorry

New Number: wait did I wake you??

New Number: omg nvm

New Number: I'm sorry again

New Number: I'll leave you alone

New Number: have a good night!

Me: No, no, no

Me: Don’t go now

Me: I’m invested now

Me: I need to know who this person is and what exactly they did to you to piss you off so bad

New Number: don't want to let you down, but it's probably not that interesting

New Number: just my sister

Me: No offense, wrong number, but with as much fire you just spat at me through text???

Me: I doubt it’s not interesting

New Number: okay

New Number: do you want the short story or the long one?

Me: Loooong

Me: I’m awake and I have my popcorn

Me: Take me to pettyville

New Number: omg pettyville

New Number: maybe that's where she should move with her fiance

New Number: but I'll back up

Me: Excellent

Me: I love a good backstory

New Number: I don't exactly get along with my sister

New Number: but she came to visit today

New Number: and things were kind of going okay? sort of??

New Number: but then she got mad (like she always does) and “dropped” my phone in my water glass

Me: Wtf??

New Number: thank you!!!

New Number: she said it was an accident but how is that an accident???

Me: Yeah, no

Me: That’s definitely not an accident

Me: An accident is when you misjudge your landing whilst parkouring through the kitchen and your mother has to take you to the ER

New Number: okay that sounds like a story

Me: Not dunking your sister’s phone in a glass of water

New Number: ty ty

New Number: anyway a big fight and nearly getting kicked out of the restaurant later

New Number: she finally leaves and I get a chance to look at the damage

New Number: nothing worked so I had to go to the store to get a new one and couldn't transfer anything and I don't even know how to use this one I got

Me: Omg I would be furious

Me: Figuring out new phones is the worst

New Number: right??

New Number: so I made myself a strong margarita and tried to figure it out

New Number: then I somehow convinced myself to let her have it but needed some courage sooooo

New Number: I drank a second margarita

New Number: and that's how you had me blowing up your phone at midnight

Me: My gosh

New Number: sorry about that btw

New Number: and this whole nonsense

New Number: is that interesting enough?

Me: Riveting

Me: You know what though, wrong number?

Me: I’m beginning to think fate has brought us together

New Number: fate? or my sister?

Me: Why not both?

Me: It sounds like what you need is a prankster

Me: And I just so happen to be in such a line of work

New Number: oh really?

New Number: go on

Me: Ok ok

Me: So while I agree that your sister deserves your angry texts, she’s probably expecting that

Me: It’s what she wants...right?

New Number: tbh waking her up was also a goal

New Number: but you have a point

New Number: you think i should ghost her?

Me: No, I think you should fight fire with fire

Me: Or more specifically

Me: Jello

New Number: jello?

New Number: wait

New Number: you think I should put her phone in jello?

New Number: like in the office?

Me: That’s exactly what I’m suggesting

Me: She put your phone in water

Me: Steal her phone and put it in jello

Me: Also the office is a good show, don’t laugh

New Number: parks and rec is better

Me: I’m going to pretend you didn’t say that for the sake of our new friendship, wrong number

New Number: okay let me think

New Number: first I have to convince her to come back, then I have to get the phone away from her somehow

New Number: but if I back up her stuff first...

Me: I can practically see the wheels turning in your head

Me: Can you invite her over for a breakfast truce? Then snatch it while she isn’t looking?

New Number: yes!

New Number: you’re a genius

New Number: I’ll invite her to brunch

New Number: she LOVES brunch

New Number: then I attack???

Me: THEN YOU ATTACK

New Number: lol okay

New Number: ugh I better go to bed

New Number: have to wake up early to get to the store and buy some jello 0:)

New Number: … is it weird if I save your number?

New Number: I only have like 3 contacts rn

Me: Not at all

Me: I’m an accomplice to your scheme now

Me: I expect a full report tomorrow

New Number: I’ll keep you posted

New Number: might take a few days to convince her but I’m going to do it

New Number: hold me to that

Me: Will do

Me: Talk to you later then?

New Number: number saved (:

--

She had been right to set a few alarms.

Staying up later than usual was probably a mistake. It was already going to make waking up on time more difficult.

To add to that, Lily could be a pretty deep sleeper. Since freshman year, when she shared a small room and bunk bed with her best friend, she had gotten used to the particular jingle of her alarm. By the third week of class, the alarm from the bed below hers didn’t make her stir. While other people - most people, admittedly - would have heard and woken to another alarm, she wouldn’t wake unless it was the right tune for her.

So having a different alarm from a new phone this morning was a minor disaster.

“Get. Up. Evans.”

Each word was punctuated with a perfectly targeted pillow hit.

Lily groaned and tried to bat away the offending pillow. “What?”

“Get up.”

Rolling over, Lily saw her roommate with a pillow and early morning death glare. Mary managed to look a little threatening, even with her tousled bed head and faded Class Of t-shirt. “Turn off your freaking alarm. Some of us don’t have early morning classes for a reason.”

“My what?” Lily mumbled, rubbing the sleep out of her eye.

“Your alarm. It’s been going off for like ten minutes.” Mary pointed past Lily to the heating and cooling unit she used as her bedside table. On top of it, her shiny new phone vibrated along with the unfamiliar melody that was, apparently, supposed to wake her.

“Oh, fu-” Lily grabbed the phone and poked it into silence. “Sorry.”

Mary hummed a testy response. She hugged the pillow to her chest and turned to the door. “You’re lucky I like you.”

“I know, I know,” Lily answered. “I’ll buy you coffee later to make up for it. And I’ll play around with the alarms so it doesn’t happen again.” She started to click though the alarm app to find her options. “I’m not used to the new one and -”

With a jolt, she noticed the time.

Lily jumped out of bed and threw her comforter back, startling Mary in the process. “I’m late. I have to run somewhere before class. Do I have time?”

Her roommate had lived with her long enough to know when to make herself scarce. It also gave her an easy exit to go back to sleep until she had to wake up for her own classes.

In a whirlwind, Lily found a dress in her closet and tugged on her reliable pair of black flats. She quickly packed up her laptop and notebooks while brushing her teeth. There wasn’t time for breakfast, but she might be able to find something at the store.

“See you later!” she called behind her, closing their front door. In a gesture that was a few seconds too late to be helpful, Lily ensured that she had the keys for her apartment in the front pocket of her backpack.

Partway down the street, her phone vibrated again. This time, it wasn’t an alarm.

Parks and Rec: Rise and shine, wrong number!

Me: why are you also up at this hour???

Parks and Rec: Jogging

Parks and Rec: Or finishing up at least

Me: you woke up early to RUN?

Me: I almost slept through my alarm

Parks and Rec: I wake up early every morning to run

Parks and Rec: Have since high school

Me: sounds healthy

Me: but oh god at what cost?

Parks and Rec: The cost of being dashingly fit

She already missed her alarm, but Lily fell into another Millennial stereotype when she looked down at her phone as she walked. While tapping out her response with her thumbs, she had to backspace a few times to make up for the difference between this keyboard and her old one.

Me: (draft) I’m on my way to grab the jello but

Lily came up short when she bumped into another person, a hand catching her. The phone nearly flew out of her hand. Thankfully, she caught it, since she wasn’t sure her bank account could take the hit of a second new phone in two days.

“Whoa there,” the voice attached to the hand said. “You okay?”

“Sorry. I didn’t -”

She looked up from the luckily uncracked screen of her phone. Then, she had to tilt her chin back farther to meet the other person’s eyes. They were hidden behind a thick pair of glasses frames but still quite alert for this time of day. They were also incredibly hazel, a swirl of several colors in one, and Lily thought to herself that hazel was a truly underappreciated shade.

She blinked a few times, trying to ground herself.

Instead of steadying her, the dull sparks from the place where his hand was touching her arm made her legs a little shaky. What was happening to her? “Thanks,” she said quietly. Lily withdrew her arm to hold the phone closer to her. “Sorry again. Got distracted.”

“It’s alright. No worries,” he said kindly. His head tilted slightly. “Hey, aren’t you in my Bio class?”

That was probably why his mussed hair looked so familiar. With that context, she could picture him in the seat a row back from her in their Bio section. She also remembered Mary’s pointed comments about her potentially being a little distracted in Biology when she met Lily after class one day.

"Yeah, I think so," Lily answered. "I was actually hoping to grab something before class, but I'm not off to the best start."

“Well, if you slip in a few minutes late, I doubt Binns will notice,” he said, his lips twitching. “Honestly, I don’t think he even knows who is in the class.”

Lily felt her own lips follow his into a smile. "Maybe you could save me a seat."

“Of course. As long as you don’t mind sitting in the back.”

"I think I can handle that for one lecture." Her phone buzzed, reminding her that the shrinking time before class was passing quickly. She shifted on her feet and put a hand on the strap of her bag. "See you there?"

“See you there,” he confirmed, taking a few steps back and saluting her.

Without moving, Lily watched him go. When he turned suddenly back toward her a few feet later, she hoped he was too far away to notice her blush at being caught.

“Hey!” he called, his voice carrying to her. “What’s your name, by the way?”

"Evans," she answered. Then, shaking her head, she added, "Lily Evans." She brushed some loose hair behind her ear a little self consciously. "Who will I be sitting next to?"

“James Potter,” he said. She could tell he was grinning, so bright that she could see it even with the distance between them. “Nice to meet you.”

"I'll see you soon, James." It was something of a promise and call to action for herself. She had to run to the store at the end of the road, find a little box of Jello mix, and get to class before it was too late.

She couldn't let someone else take her seat.

--

“Not another word.”

“I haven’t said anything!”

“You’ve been cackling for the past twenty minutes!”

“Oh, I have not.”

“You laughed the whole way home! You haven’t stopped laughing since we left class!”

“You’re being dramatic. Has anyone ever told you that?”

James rolled his eyes, turning to give his best friend a deadpan expression as he unlocked the door. He was met by another series of poorly repressed snorts as Sirius broke down into laughter… again.

Honestly, he really ought to take better care of who he allowed to be in his inner circle. He didn’t realize that he was subjecting himself to being mocked for all eternity by entering into a lifetime of friendship with Sirius Black.

Damn their blood pact they made at age eleven.

“Sirius…”

“I just - I can’t help it!”

“Fine,” huffed James. “You can stay outside until you collect yourself, then.”

Sirius’ well placed foot was the only thing that stopped James from slamming the door in his face. James didn’t have to look at him to know that Sirius propped himself against the wall for support as he continued to laugh. He chucked his keys down on the counter with a huff.

“You pay me to switch seats for the morning so you could sit next to some girl. You beg me to do this for you,” said Sirius through his laughter. “Then you can’t even speak to her!”

“It’s Bio, Sirius. Not dinner,” argued James for what felt like the thousandth time. “How am I supposed to talk to her in class? We’re supposed to be paying attention!”

“Pass notes or something,” countered Sirius, wiping away his tears. “Not just sit there, staring straight ahead like she’s not there. I’m not sure you even blinked the whole time.”

James groaned, tugging at his hair. “She’s pretty, Sirius. She’s so pretty that it makes me stupid! I don’t know what to say to her! It’s a miracle that I even managed to make small talk with her before class.”

“It will be another miracle if she talks to you again after this morning.”

“What if she thinks I hate her? What if this was my one chance and I blew it? God, why couldn’t I think to ask her for tutoring or something? I could have said that I’m rubbish at Bio.”

“You are rubbish at Bio,” said Sirius, yawning. Apparently laughing himself silly over James’ stupidity left him tired. “It’s not too late to tell her that.”

“I’m not that bad at it,” muttered James. He was, though. “I’m just better at other things.”

“God, you sound like Mia. That’s something she’s actually told you before, isn’t it?”

“Shut up about my mother. At least she believes in me.”

“Not after I tell her about this.”

“Don’t you dare,” hissed James, jabbing a finger in his direction. “Don’t you mention a word of this to Mum.”

“I’ll take hush money in the form of McDonald’s.”

“I already paid you today!”

“That was for switching seats,” Sirius argued. “This is for my silence.”

“Fine,” growled James. “What does this say about you as my best mate? All this bribery?”

“It says you’re a bit of a chump. Now, if you’ll excuse me, I’m late for my afternoon nap. These early morning classes are really taking it out of me. When I wake up, I expect a ten piece nugget. Don’t forget the Coke!”

James opened his mouth to protest, but Sirius had already retreated to his bedroom, leaving James to slump sadly onto the couch. He stared blankly at the television. He wasn’t even sure Netflix could solve his depression at this point.

Why couldn’t he just talk to her?

He felt so confident after running into Lily at the end of his morning jog. He learned her name! He had spent so long wondering who she was and what her name could possibly be that it must have completely fried his brain once he finally knew it.

That was the only explanation.

Or, one of them, at least.

The other being that he was a walking disaster.

Both were probably true.

Sighing, James pulled out his phone. His conversation with the wrong number from last night was still open. Before he realized what he was doing, he found his fingers typing.

Me: I’ve had such a weird day, wrong number

Me: How has your day been?

Into the Unknown: had to appease my roommate with some coffee but it’s all right

Into the Unknown: what’s up?

His lips twitched down at his phone. This felt easy.

Me: Just one of those days where you feel awkward and want the earth to open up and swallow you whole

Me: You ever have those?

Into the Unknown: omg have you been reading my 8th grade diary???

Into the Unknown: I think I wrote that exact phrase every other day

Me: I knew you got me

Into the Unknown: btw do you think a phone can survive in the refrigerator for a few hours?

Me: Ehh, who cares about the phone? She destroyed yours.

Me: An eye for an eye. A phone for a phone.

Into the Unknown: I feel weird about destroying it

Into the Unknown: can I uninstall guilt?

Me: Ha, I don’t think guilt works that way

Me: But how awesome would it be if it did?

Me: Very important question - What flavor jello did you get?

Into the Unknown: cherry

Into the Unknown: my sister hates cherry flavor

Me: Oooo I love the flavor of petty

Me: Nice going

Into the Unknown: why was your day weird?

Into the Unknown: unless you don’t want to talk about it

Me: It’s just…

Me: Without going into too much detail, it’s about a girl

Into the Unknown: we haven’t actually established this yet but *fun fact* I’m a girl

Into the Unknown: maybe I can help?

Into the Unknown: unless you don’t want to talk about it!

Into the Unknown: this isn’t exactly cracking a cold one with the boys

Into the Unknown: or chatting with your girl friends

Into the Unknown: or whatever

Into the Unknown: ignore me if you want

Me: A cold one with the boys?? Really??

Me: How did you guess that I’m a disaster of a male

Into the Unknown: tbh I mostly said it for the meme

Into the Unknown: I can try to help regardless of the gender of your disaster

Into the Unknown: though I’m sure it’s not as bad as you think

Me: Oh I’m sure it’s much worse

Me: It’s bad enough for me to owe my best mate hush money so he doesn’t tell my mum what an embarrassment I am

Into the Unknown: did you say something to her?

Me: No, that’s the thing

Me: I can’t talk to her

Me: I don’t know how

Me: She makes me nervous

Into the Unknown: then it can’t be that bad

Into the Unknown: stg some guys set the bar so low

Into the Unknown: what about her makes you nervous?

Me: Do I sound like a jerk if I say it’s because she’s pretty? Bc she’s so pretty

Me: But it’s more than that

Me: I can tell she’s kind and smart

Me: It’s like… have you ever met a person and just wanted to get to know them better? Like something in you is drawn to them?

Into the Unknown: you don’t sound like a jerk

Into the Unknown: you sound like you have a crush

Me: Crushes are so painful

Into the Unknown: guess I should check this before giving too much advice

Into the Unknown: are you in high school?

Me: No I’m in college

Me: WAIT

Me: Are YOU in high school?

Into the Unknown: no, I'm in college too

Into the Unknown: so okay

Into the Unknown: you have a crush on a girl

Me: A very pretty, unattainable girl

Into the Unknown: unattainable?

Into the Unknown: okay first step might be making sure you're not putting her on some impossible pedestal

Into the Unknown: have you ever talked to her?

Me: … I have said a few words

Me: I asked her for her name and I told her mine

Into the Unknown: okay progress!

Into the Unknown: maybe she wants to get to know you too

Into the Unknown: are you going to see her again?

Me: Yeah we have class together

Me: But it’s just the one and it’s super hard to talk in class

Me: Especially when said class is your worst subject and you need to be paying attention or you’ll fail

Into the Unknown: valid. a crush is not worth failing a class!

Into the Unknown: sounds like you need to find a way to talk after class and see if she wants to get to know you too

Into the Unknown: is she good at this class?

Me: She answers questions in class

Me: And laughs at the corny science jokes I don’t get

Into the Unknown: aw she's a nerd

Into the Unknown: you can ask her about the class

Me: Yeah that’s a good idea

Me: Hey thanks

Me: My best mate just made fun of me for choking in front of her

Into the Unknown: that's kind of what best friends are for

Into the Unknown: mine attacked me with a pillow this morning

Me: Jesus maybe we need new friends lol

Me: I really appreciate the honest help, you know?

Into the Unknown: idk how much I helped but I can try

Into the Unknown: give her a chance to get to know you

Into the Unknown: maybe you even make her a little nervous too

Me: HA

Me: I siriusly doubt that

Me: thanks again though, wrong number

Into the Unknown: you never know!

Into the Unknown: let me know how it goes

Me: Will do

Me: ttyl, I owe my best mate some McDonald’s

Me: (long story)

Into the Unknown: okay fine I’ll do some homework

Into the Unknown: have a milkshake for me